After a few tries of reverting to my backups and trying to re-upgrade them, as well as trying to use both the full version of the download as well as the no-interface one, I checked my web server logs, and noticed this:
PHP Fatal error: Call to undefined function escapse_array() in C:\\Apache2\\htdocs\\roster\\settings.php on line 153, referer: http://ironsong.gotdns.com:10152/roster/upgrade.php
It would seem that "escape_array" was mispelled, causing the script to stop and not bring up anything. After I corrected the spelling, the roster is working fine.
Just a heads up in case anyone else experiences this issue.