Absolute pish and tosh,
I've been running the guild roster with your wonderful roster installed plus some magnificent 3rd party addons.
We had some initial problems convincing people to use it, had to hide the mailbox, the bags, and bank and gold for characters, and people then started to drift in.
But this weekend the Guild leader and one other guy had a trojan installed from a pop up on http://ui.worldofwar.net ( warnign there then) which passed on their details to someone. The GM's account was raped and three of the guild banks. Gutted eh. Now the GM know it isnt roster, but the small minded few who mistrust it and somehow think that displaying their character will enable someone to have their username and password.
I hope you can appriciate how frustrated I am about this and their small mindedness, but they had a poll vote and the majority didint trust it,
stupid breeds stupid